Dana says: This
was my first George MacDonald book and was recommended for my Ladies' Book Club by a few of my girlfriends who love it. I did enjoy
it even though I felt like I was reading a children's book. I normally
do not read fantasy and found the creativity and imagination of
MacDonald to be delightful. His depiction of the cob's animals was one
of my favorite parts. I also liked the sweet relationship between Irene
and her King-papa and the some of the conversations between Irene and
Curdie and Curdie and his mother about believing and understanding. I
kept waiting for a twist or major revelation of some kind at the end but
there really wasn't anything like that.
I think Irene's great
great grandmother in this book is supposed to be some kind of God-type
figure but she seemed very strange to me and for most of the book I
wasn't sure if she was good or evil. I think I expected her to be more
of a figure like Aslan is in the Narnia series than what George
MacDonald portrays in this book. Maybe I will change my mind after the
Ladies' Book Club discussion...
No comments:
Post a Comment